Grouper sandwich
Covers Orlando's restaurants, bars and local plates, with menu prices checked on the date shown.
UpdatedThis page carries dated prices or seasonal dates checked on the date above, and that window has now passed. Re-check the sources at the foot of the page before you book anything.
A grouper sandwich is a fillet of grouper, grilled, blackened or fried, on a bun with lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce. Grouper is a firm, mild, large-flaked white fish from reef waters, and red and black grouper are both caught in the Gulf off Florida. At The Boathouse in Disney Springs, the Grilled Grouper Sandwich with chipotle tartar sauce and fries costs $33 in September 2026.
It is also the fish Florida has faked most famously. In 2006 the Tampa Bay Times exposed widespread substitution of other species for grouper. When Oceana DNA-tested fish in South Florida in 2012, it found grouper mislabeling had fallen from 40–50% at the height of the scam in the mid-2000s to 16%, about one sample in six. Lower is not zero.
At a glance
- What it is
- A grilled, blackened or fried fillet of grouper, a firm, mild white reef fish, on a bun
- Substitution risk
- Oceana found 16% of grouper samples mislabeled in South Florida in 2012, down from 40–50% in the mid-2000s
- Common fakes
- Pangasius (Asian catfish), tilapia, king mackerel, weakfish and cheaper grouper species
- Price around Orlando
- Grilled Grouper Sandwich $33 at The Boathouse, Disney Springs
- What to ask
- Which species of grouper, where it was caught, and whether it was frozen
- The law
- Florida Statutes s. 509.292 bars knowingly serving one food under the name of another
In this guide
The substitution problem, in the tests
The evidence is specific. In Oceana's 2012 South Florida testing, the three fake grouper samples were a different species every time: Pangasius, a farmed Asian catfish; weakfish; and king mackerel. King mackerel is on federal advice lists for women of childbearing age and young children because of its mercury levels.
Oceana's national study, published in 2013, found 26% of grouper samples mislabeled (11 of 43), and five of 16 grouper meals bought in restaurants. Substitutes included Pangasius, freshwater perch, weakfish, bream and other grouper species, some of them endangered. The FDA allows 58 species to be sold simply as "grouper", so even a real grouper may not be the one you think.
In 2016 the Tampa Bay Times ran the Farm to Fable investigation. A "fresh grouper" sushi roll at a Tampa restaurant was DNA-tested at the University of South Florida. It was tilapia.
What has changed since
Two things work in your favor. Florida law already makes it an offense to knowingly serve one food under the name of another (Florida Statutes s. 509.292). And since January 1, 2018, imported grouper has been covered by NOAA's Seafood Import Monitoring Program, which requires catch records for 13 species groups. That program only traces fish to the US border, though, not to your plate.
Oceana's 2019 national testing did not re-test grouper, but it found a Florida "hogfish" that was really spinycheek grouper, an Indian Ocean species, and another that was Pangasius. Swaps of local names for imported fish are still happening.
How to order one without getting fooled
- Ask which grouper. Red or black grouper is a real answer. "Just grouper" is not.
- Ask where it was caught. Gulf or South Atlantic grouper is local. A kitchen that knows will tell you.
- Look at the price. Real local grouper is expensive. A bargain basket is the likeliest place for a substitute.
- Taste and texture. Grouper is firm with big, moist flakes. Soft, mushy or very thin fillets are a reason to ask more questions.
Where to eat it around Orlando
Orlando is inland, so grouper here has always traveled. For visitors, the clearest menu is at The Boathouse in Disney Springs: the Grilled Grouper Sandwich is $33, and a Pan-Seared Gulf Grouper entree is $48.50. At Summer House on the Lake, also in Disney Springs, grouper fish and chips are $35.95. Paddlefish lists a Florida Grouper entree at $48, a price we could not confirm as current.
Those prices are the honest benchmark: a sandwich that claims local grouper at a fraction of that deserves your questions. If you want grouper where it is landed, a Tampa day trip puts you on the Gulf coast.
Frequently asked questions
Is the grouper in Florida restaurants really grouper?
Usually, but not always. Oceana's 2012 South Florida DNA testing found 16% of grouper samples mislabeled, down from 40–50% in the mid-2000s. Its 2013 national study found five of 16 restaurant grouper samples were something else.
What fish is sold as fake grouper?
Tests have found Pangasius (Asian catfish), tilapia, king mackerel, weakfish, freshwater perch, bream and cheaper or imported grouper species sold under the grouper name.
How much is a grouper sandwich in Orlando?
At The Boathouse in Disney Springs, the Grilled Grouper Sandwich is $33 with fries, as listed on its menu on September 22, 2026.
How can you tell if grouper is real?
You cannot be sure without a DNA test. Ask for the species and where it was caught, be wary of cheap prices, and expect firm, large, moist flakes. Soft or mushy fish is a reason to ask more questions.
Is it illegal to sell fake grouper in Florida?
Yes. Florida Statutes s. 509.292 prohibits knowingly and willfully serving a food under the name of another food.
Further reading
Official sources
- The Boathouse - menu (official, via its Yext menu feed) – Grilled Grouper Sandwich $33 with lettuce, tomato, chipotle tartar and fries; Pan-Seared Gulf Grouper $48.50; checked September 22, 2026
- Oceana - Persistent Seafood Fraud Found in South Florida (July 2012) – Grouper mislabeled 16% (3 of 19); down from 40-50% in the mid-2000s; substitutes Pangasius, weakfish and king mackerel; checked September 22, 2026
- Oceana - National Seafood Fraud Testing Results (February 2013) – Grouper 26% mislabeled (11 of 43), 5 of 16 restaurant samples; substitutes; FDA lists 58 species sellable as grouper; checked September 22, 2026
- Oceana - Casting a Wider Net (March 2019) – Florida hogfish samples that were spinycheek grouper and Pangasius; 21% of 449 fish mislabeled; checked September 22, 2026
- Tampa Bay Times - Farm to Fable (April 13, 2016) – Times' 2006 grouper substitution exposure; 'fresh grouper' roll DNA-tested at USF was tilapia; checked September 22, 2026
- NOAA Fisheries - Seafood Import Monitoring Program – Grouper among 13 covered species groups; compliance from January 1, 2018; checked September 22, 2026
- Florida Statutes s. 509.292 - Misrepresenting food (Florida Senate) – Knowingly serving a food under the name of another is prohibited; checked September 22, 2026
- ThemeParkIQ - Disney menu search (grouper) – Summer House on the Lake grouper fish and chips $35.95; Paddlefish Florida Grouper $48 (entry last updated about a year earlier); checked September 22, 2026
